Skip to main content

California's Dispute Resolution Community

AGREEMENT TO ARBITRATE

Garcia v. Stoneledge Furniture LLC, 102 Cal. App. 5 th 41

Vazquez v. SaniSure, Inc., 101 Cal. App. 5 th 139

West v. Solar Mosaic LLC, 105 Cal. App. 5 th 985Garcia v. Stoneledge Furniture LLC, 102 Cal. App. 5 th 41



Garcia v. Stoneledge Furniture LLC, 102 Cal. App. 5 th 41

Garcia sued RAC, her employer, and two others, alleging sexual harassment. The defendantsmoved to compel arbitration based on an electronic agreement that Garcia purportedlysigned when she was hired by RAC. The agreement was introduced through a declarationby a member of RAC’s HR staff, that stated that Garcia entered RAC’s system, using herpassword, and signed several agreements, including the arbitration agreement. Garciadenied signing the agreement and cited several differences in the arbitration agreementfrom the other electronic agreements, including the fact that the arbitration agreementbore a different version of Garcia’s name than the other agreements. The trial court deniedthe motion and the defendants appealed.The Court of Appeal affirmed. RAC bore the burden to prove the authenticity of thesignature on the arbitration agreement. A proponent seeking to authenticate an electronicsignature must show the electronic signature was the act of the person, which could beshown in any manner, including a showing of the efficacy of any security procedure appliedto determine the person to which the electronic record or electronic signature wasattributable. RAC failed to carry its burden because the evidence it provided did not showthat only Garcia could have placed the electronic signature on the arbitration agreement.The HR representative did not explain how he knew that the name “Maria Isabel IzzyGarcia” could have only been placed on the agreement using Garcia's user ID and passwordand not the other onboarding documents. Instead, he summarily concluded that Garciaelectronically signed and acknowledged the agreement before exiting out of the system,with the only purported evidence being her name on the agreement. This was insufficientto meet the authentication requirements.




Vazquez v. SaniSure, Inc., 101 Cal. App. 5 th 139

Plaintiff signed an arbitration agreement when shewas hired by SaniSure in November2019. She resigned in May 2021, but rejoined the company in September 2021. She did notsign an arbitration agreement during her second stint with SaniSure. She resigned in July2022 and subsequently sued SaniSure, alleging violation of the labor laws. SaniSure’smotion to compel arbitration was denied on the grounds that there was no arbitrationagreement covering the second period of employment.SaniSure appealed and the Court of Appeal affirmed. Vazquez signed arbitrationagreements during her first stint of at-will employment with SaniSure. But she revokedthese agreements by terminating her employment in May 2021. The causes of action inVazquez's lawsuit were based on events that allegedly occurred only during her secondstint of employment with SaniSure. Vazquez did not sign a second set of arbitrationagreements during that stint of employment. Thus, for her claims to be subject toarbitration, SaniSure had to show that the parties agreed that the agreements Vazquezsigned during her first stint of employment would apply to her second. SaniSure did not doso. Vazquez testified that she never agreed that the agreements she signed during her firststint of employment would govern her second. She also said that SaniSure never told herthat getting rehired was contingent on agreeing to arbitration. And the documents shesigned upon rehiring did not mention arbitration. SaniSure thus failed to carry its burdenof showing that the trial court erred as a matter of law when it denied the motion to compelarbitration.



West v. Solar Mosaic LLC, 105 Cal. App. 5 th 985Garcia v. Stoneledge Furniture LLC, 102 Cal. App. 5 th 41

A representative of Elite Construction called on Harold West and his wife at their home andsuccessfully induced them to enter a contract to install a new bathroom as well as solarpanels on the roof. The construction would be financed by a $25,000 loan from Solar. TheWests were in their 90s and suffered from dementia. Neither had a computer or cellphone.They were aided in the negotiations by their daughter Deon. A representative of Solar sentthe loan agreement to Deon’s cellphone and talked to Harold. The conversation wasrecorded and indicated that Harold had difficulty providing his age and social securitynumber as well as the month and date. Nevertheless, he purportedly signed and initialedthe 33-page agreement within 23 seconds after its delivery. After work commenced on theproject, Deon discovered the loan agreement. Harold denied signing it and asserted that hethought that he had agreed to a free government program repairing homes for destituteseniors. They filed suit to rescind the loan and force Elite to complete the project. Solar’smotion to compel arbitration based on a clause in the agreement was denied on the groundthat it failed to prove that there was an agreement and it appealed.The Court of Appeal affirmed. Solar argued the trial court's ruling on the motion to compelarbitration was erroneous because once Solar met its initial burden of production and theburden shifted to the Wests, they failed to submit evidence sufficient to meet their burdenof demonstrating a factual dispute as to the authenticity of Harold's electronic signatures.The Court of Appeal observed that Solar was incorrect. The loan documents were sent toDeon's e-mail address, Deon told the Solar representative she would go check her e-mail,the documents were opened on a mobile phone 10 seconds after being sent, they werecompleted with seven electronic signatures within the space of 13 seconds, and Deonconfirmed the documents' completion. Harold was in his 90's, suffered from dementia, didnot use a computer, mobile phone, or e-mail, and was unable to answer simple questionssuch as his birth date and telephone number without assistance and significant delay. Theevidence strongly suggested Harold lacked the technical facility to open his daughter'semail on what was presumably her mobile phone, create a digital signature, electronicallyclick through and execute the loan agreement in seven locations, and submit thosesignatures, all in the space of 23 seconds, and it unquestionably demonstrated the existenceof a factual dispute as to whether Harold actually executed the electronic signatures on theloan documents.